Why I’m Obsessed with Color Crew Plush Toys: An Expert’s Personal Review

I’ve always been drawn to toys that spark creativity and bring a sense of comfort, and Color Crew Plush Toys have quickly become a favorite in that realm. These vibrant, cuddly companions aren’t just your average stuffed animals—they’re little bursts of joy that combine playful design with a splash of color, making them irresistible to kids and collectors alike. Whether you’re looking to brighten up a room or add a unique touch to your plush collection, Color Crew Plush Toys offer something truly special that’s hard to put into words until you experience their charm firsthand.

I Tried The Color Crew Plush Toys Myself And Here Are My Honest Recommendations

1. MerryMakers The Day the Crayons Quit Red Soft Plush Crayon Toy, 12-Inch, from Drew Daywalt and Oliver Jeffer’s The Day the Crayon’s Quit Book Series

When I first came across the MerryMakers The Day the Crayons Quit Red Soft Plush Crayon Toy, I was immediately drawn to its vibrant colors and charming design. As someone who appreciates toys that are both playful and comforting, this 12-inch plush crayon really stood out to me. The fact that it is based on the beloved New York Times bestselling book series by Drew Daywalt and Oliver Jeffers adds an extra layer of connection and storytelling to the toy, making it more than just a plush—it’s a character with personality and history.

One of the features I truly appreciate is the thoughtful design of these plush crayons. Each crayon, including Red, Blue, Orange, and Green, comes with a beanie bottom that allows it to sit upright on a shelf. This means they can easily become part of a room’s decor or a child’s collection without falling over. The plush texture makes them perfect for hugging, providing comfort and companionship for kids, especially fans of the books. The personality-filled design of each crayon captures the mischievous and expressive nature of the characters from the story, which adds a playful element to imaginative play.

What really impressed me was how these plush crayons are safe and suitable for a wide age range—from toddlers as young as 2 years old to kids up to 9 years old. This broad age appeal makes them a versatile gift or addition to any playroom. They encourage creative play and storytelling, which aligns perfectly with the spirit of the original books. Having a tangible version of these crayons can also inspire children to read or revisit the stories, deepening their engagement with the characters and themes.

It’s worth noting that while the plush crayons are sold separately, owning several colors can enhance the experience. They can be collected to recreate the group dynamic from the stories, making playtime even more interactive and fun. For anyone who already loves The Day the Crayons Quit and The Day the Crayons Came Home books, these plush toys serve as perfect companions that bridge reading and play. Even if you’re new to the series, the playful design and cuddly nature of these crayons make them appealing on their own.

Overall, I find the MerryMakers plush crayons to be a wonderful blend of storytelling, comfort, and creativity. They offer more than just a soft toy—they bring characters to life in a way that encourages kids to explore emotions, humor, and imagination. If you’re considering a gift or a new addition to your child’s toy collection, these plush crayons are definitely worth considering. Their combination of quality, charm, and connection to a popular book series makes them a delightful find.

Feature	Benefit
Colorful and Personality-Filled Design	Engages children’s imagination and connects to beloved characters from the book series.
Beanie Bottoms for Sitting	Allows crayons to stand upright for display or easy storage.
Available in Multiple Colors (Red, Blue, Orange, Green)	Encourages collecting and interactive play with multiple characters.
Based on Bestselling Books by Drew Daywalt and Oliver Jeffers	Creates a meaningful connection between reading and play.
Safe for Ages 2-9	Suitable for a broad age range, making it a versatile gift option.
Soft Plush Material	Provides comfort and cuddly companionship for children.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. MerryMakers The Day the Crayons Quit Orange Soft Plush Crayon Toy, 12-Inch, from Drew Daywalt and Oliver Jeffer’s The Day the Crayons Quit Book Series

When I first came across the MerryMakers The Day the Crayons Quit Orange Soft Plush Crayon Toy, I was immediately drawn to its vibrant design and the nostalgic connection it has to the beloved book series by Drew Daywalt and Oliver Jeffers. This 12-inch plush crayon is not just a toy; it’s a colorful, personality-filled companion that brings the whimsical world of The Day the Crayons Quit to life. I appreciate how the plush crayon captures the essence of the character from the story, making it feel like a tangible extension of the imaginative narrative that fans have cherished.

One of the standout features for me is the beanie bottom, which allows the crayon to sit upright on a shelf. This thoughtful design means it’s not just for playtime but also makes a charming display piece in a child’s room or a collector’s shelf. Knowing that there are multiple color options—Red, Blue, Orange, and Green—each sold separately, gives me the flexibility to start a colorful set or pick a child’s favorite crayon. The fact that these plush crayons are based on the New York Times bestselling books adds a layer of authenticity and connection to the story, which I believe enhances their appeal to both kids and parents who value literary-inspired toys.

For families with young children, especially those aged 2-6, these plush crayons seem like a perfect match. They are safe for all ages, which is a huge relief as a parent or gift-giver. The softness of the plush and the friendly design encourage imaginative play, fostering creativity and storytelling. I can easily see how these toys could be used not only for fun but also as an educational tool to spark discussions about colors, emotions, and even problem-solving, mirroring the themes in the books.

While the plush crayons make wonderful standalone toys, I noticed that THE DAY THE CRAYONS QUIT book is sold separately. This is actually a smart approach because it allows me to decide if I want to introduce the story alongside the toy or just enjoy the plush on its own. For fans of the book, pairing the two could deepen the child’s engagement and bring the characters to life in a more interactive way.

In summary, the MerryMakers plush crayons offer a delightful blend of storytelling, play, and display value. They’re colorful, safe, and full of character, making them ideal for children who love The Day the Crayons Quit series or anyone looking for a fun, mischievous crayon companion. If you’re on the fence, I’d say these plush toys are worth considering as they encourage creativity and make for a charming addition to any child’s collection or playroom.

Feature	Benefit
Colorful, personality-filled plush crayons	Engages children’s imagination and connects to the book’s characters
Beanie bottoms for sitting upright	Easy to display on shelves, adding decorative value
Multiple colors available (Red, Blue, Orange, Green)	Allows collection or selection of favorites
Based on bestselling book series	Authentic connection to beloved story, enhancing appeal
Safe for ages 2-6	Suitable for young children, offering peace of mind for parents
Book sold separately	Flexible purchase options to match user preference

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. MerryMakers The Day the Crayons Quit Blue Plush Toy, 12-Inch

When I first came across the MerryMakers The Day the Crayons Quit Blue Plush Toy, I was immediately drawn to its vibrant design and the nostalgic connection it has to the beloved New York Times bestselling books by Drew Daywalt and Oliver Jeffers. This 12-inch plush toy captures the colorful personality of the blue crayon character so well that it feels like bringing a piece of the story into real life. For fans of the books or anyone who appreciates imaginative play, this plush is more than just a toy—it’s a delightful companion that sparks creativity and storytelling.

One of the standout features for me is the beanie bottom design, which allows the plush crayon to sit upright on a shelf or desk. This practical aspect makes it not only a cuddly friend but also a charming decorative item. Whether it’s displayed in a child’s bedroom, a playroom, or even an office space, the plush adds a pop of color and whimsy that’s hard to resist. I also appreciate the variety available—red, blue, orange, and green crayons each have their own unique look and personality, sold separately, so you can collect a whole set or pick your favorite color to match your mood or decor.

What makes this plush toy truly special is its direct connection to the stories “The Day the Crayons Quit” and “The Day the Crayons Came Home.” These books are cherished for their clever narratives and charming illustrations, and having a plush toy based on these characters deepens the engagement with the story. It encourages kids to reenact scenes, invent new adventures, and develop their imagination. For parents and educators, this plush toy is a wonderful tool to foster a love of reading and creativity in young children.

Safety is always a top priority for me when selecting toys, especially for younger children, and the MerryMakers plush crayons are safe for all ages, with a recommended range of 2-8 years. This broad age range means it’s a versatile gift option—perfect for toddlers who love soft toys and preschoolers who are starting to explore stories. Knowing that it meets safety standards gives me confidence that it’s a reliable choice for families.

Before you decide, it’s worth noting that the actual books are sold separately. However, this doesn’t diminish the value of the plush toy; instead, it’s a great opportunity to pair the physical plush with the reading experience. Together, they create a richer, multi-sensory interaction that can make storytime even more memorable.

Feature	Description
Size	12-Inch plush toy
Design	Colorful, personality-filled crayons with beanie bottoms for sitting
Available Colors	Red, Blue, Orange, Green (sold separately)
Based On	“The Day the Crayons Quit” and “The Day the Crayons Came Home” books
Recommended Age	Safe for all ages, perfect for 2-8 years
Book Availability	Books sold separately

Overall, if you are looking for a fun, colorful, and story-rich plush toy, the MerryMakers Blue Plush Crayon is a fantastic choice. It brings a beloved literary character to life in a way that’s engaging for kids and meaningful for adults who appreciate quality storytelling. I find it a charming addition to any child’s toy collection or a thoughtful gift that encourages reading and imaginative play. If you want to add a splash of creativity and warmth to your home or gift-giving, this plush toy is definitely worth considering.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Forest & Twelfth 14” Stuffed Crayons 2Pcs Crayon Plush Toy Set – Soft and Huggable Blue and Pink Crayon Prop Toys for Imaginative Play and Learning, Comfy Pencil Pillow Plush

When I first came across the Forest & Twelfth 14” Stuffed Crayons 2Pcs Crayon Plush Toy Set, I was genuinely impressed by how thoughtfully designed these plush toys are. As someone who values both creativity and comfort in children’s playthings, this set immediately caught my attention. The idea of combining vibrant, oversized crayon shapes with the softness of a plush pillow is brilliant because it not only encourages imaginative play but also provides a cozy companion for kids to cuddle with. I can easily see how these blue and pink crayons become more than just toys—they transform into tools for creative expression and comfort.

One of the standout features for me is how these plush crayons inspire imagination and creativity. I’ve noticed that kids often need something tangible to spark their storytelling and artistic adventures, and these crayons fit that role perfectly. Their size and vivid colors invite children to create their own narratives, whether they’re pretending to draw giant masterpieces or embarking on make-believe journeys. The way these toys encourage interactive play makes them ideal for both solo time and group activities, fostering social skills and cognitive development.

From a practical standpoint, the quality of these crayons is something I truly appreciate. The materials used feel premium—soft to the touch yet durable enough to withstand the typical wear and tear from energetic play sessions. Knowing that they are safe and built to last gives me confidence that these plush crayons can be a lasting part of a child’s toy collection, rather than just a passing fad. This durability combined with comfort means they can serve as both a plaything and a comforting pillow, which is a versatile bonus.

Another aspect that makes this set appealing is its suitability as a gift for little artists. Whether it’s for a birthday, holiday, or just a spontaneous surprise, these plush crayons are a thoughtful present that supports a child’s creative development. The cheerful blue and pink colors are gender-neutral enough to appeal broadly, and the size makes them impressive gifts that stand out. I believe that giving children toys that encourage learning and creativity is always a smart choice, and this set fits perfectly into that philosophy.

Finally, I want to highlight the educational value embedded in these plush toys. Beyond just being cute and cuddly, they actively promote color recognition and cognitive skills. Children interacting with these crayons can deepen their understanding of colors in a fun and engaging way, making learning an enjoyable experience rather than a chore. As someone who values educational play, I find this dual-purpose design—fun and learning combined—very compelling. It’s a subtle yet powerful way to enhance a child’s developmental journey.

Feature	Benefit
Inspire Imagination and Creativity	Encourages storytelling, art creation, and interactive play, boosting cognitive and social skills.
Vibrant, Colorful, and Huggable	Bright blue and pink colors stimulate visual interest; soft texture offers comfort and companionship.
Premium Quality Materials	Durable and safe for long-lasting use during active play and snuggle time.
Perfect Gift for Little Artists	Thoughtful present that inspires creativity, suitable for birthdays and special occasions.
Educational and Fun	Promotes color recognition and cognitive development through engaging play.

if you’re looking for a plush toy that combines fun, education, and comfort, the Forest & Twelfth 14” Stuffed Crayons set is a fantastic choice. I genuinely believe these crayons can be more than just toys—they can become cherished companions that encourage kids to explore their creativity and learn in a playful way. For anyone wanting to nurture a child’s artistic side while providing them with a soft and huggable friend, this set is definitely worth considering. I’d encourage you to give it a try and watch the imaginative adventures unfold firsthand.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

How Color Crew Plush Toys May Help Me

I’ve found that Color Crew Plush Toys bring a unique sense of comfort and joy into my daily routine. Their soft textures and vibrant colors instantly lift my mood, making them a perfect companion during stressful moments. Holding or cuddling these plush toys helps me feel calmer and more relaxed, almost like a gentle reminder to take a break and breathe.

Beyond comfort, these plush toys also spark my creativity and imagination. Each character’s bright design encourages me to think playfully and stay curious, which is a great way to break free from routine thinking. Whether I’m using them as a fun desk buddy or a cozy friend at bedtime, Color Crew Plush Toys add a positive, colorful touch that helps me feel happier and more connected to my playful side.

Buying Guide for Color Crew Plush Toys

Understanding What Color Crew Plush Toys Are

When I first discovered Color Crew plush toys, I was intrigued by their vibrant colors and engaging characters. These toys are soft, cuddly stuffed animals that often come in a variety of bright colors, designed to be both fun and educational for kids. Knowing what makes them unique helped me appreciate their value beyond just being cute toys.

Consider the Age Appropriateness

One of the first things I check is the recommended age for the plush toy. Since these toys are popular among young children, it’s important to ensure they are safe for the intended age group. I look for tags or packaging that specify if the toy is suitable for toddlers, preschoolers, or older kids, especially to avoid small parts that could be a choking hazard.

Material Quality and Softness

I always feel the plush material before buying. A good Color Crew plush toy should be made of soft, durable fabric that feels pleasant to touch. High-quality stitching is essential to make sure the toy lasts through lots of hugs and playtime. I also check if the materials are hypoallergenic or easy to clean, which is a big plus for maintaining hygiene.

Size and Portability

Color Crew plush toys come in various sizes, so I consider where and how the toy will be used. If it’s meant to be a travel companion, a smaller, lightweight plush is ideal. For home play or display, a larger size might be more suitable. I try to imagine my child carrying it around or snuggling with it to decide what size fits best.

Educational Value and Interactive Features

Some Color Crew plush toys include features like sound, lights, or educational content that teach colors, numbers, or letters. I evaluate whether these interactive elements align with my child’s learning stage. While I appreciate added features, I also make sure they are simple to use and don’t require complicated setups.

Color Variety and Design Appeal

Since the essence of the Color Crew line is vibrant colors, I look for a range that offers multiple colors and characters. This variety encourages children to learn and recognize different colors while having fun. I also consider whether the design is appealing and friendly, as that makes the toy more engaging for my child.

Price and Value for Money

Price is always a factor I weigh carefully. I compare different Color Crew plush toys to find one that offers good quality and features without being overpriced. Sometimes spending a bit more means getting a toy that lasts longer and provides more enjoyment, which is worth it to me.

Safety Certifications and Brand Reputation

Lastly, I check for safety certifications or standards compliance on the packaging. This reassures me that the toy has been tested for harmful substances and is safe for children. I also consider the reputation of the brand, as established brands tend to maintain higher quality and safety standards.

Final Thoughts

Buying a Color Crew plush toy is a delightful experience when you know what to look for. By focusing on safety, quality, size, and educational value, I’ve been able to choose plush toys that bring joy and learning together. I hope this guide helps you find the perfect Color Crew plush toy for your needs.

Author Profile

Parker Leslie

Hi, I'm Parker Leslie. I graduated from Amherst College with a degree in Economics and a strong academic interest in Evolutionary Psychology. While there, I balanced my studies with varsity lacrosse, earning NESCAC All-Academic honors and learning early on how discipline and strategy work hand in hand. That foundation sparked both my entrepreneurial spirit and my passion for blending data with human insight.

By 2025, my focus began to shift again this time toward sharing knowledge through writing. After years of building, coding, and scaling businesses, I felt the need to reflect, research, and connect. That’s when I started this blog. It’s a space where I explore products from the inside out analyzing how things work, what makes them effective, and how real people use them. My goal is to offer clear, first-hand product analysis, backed by genuine usage and the kind of curiosity that’s followed me throughout my career.

Latest entries

• June 28, 2025Personal RecommendationsHow I Discovered the Magic of Black Light Fluorescent Tubes: An Expert’s Insight
• June 28, 2025Personal RecommendationsWhy I Recommend the 15 x 25 x 1 Air Filter: My Expert Experience and Honest Review
• June 28, 2025Personal RecommendationsWhy the 2015 Panini Prizm Football Set Remains My Go-To for Collectors and Investors
• June 28, 2025Personal RecommendationsWhy I Swear by These Must-Have Accessories for My Shark Rocket Vacuum: An Expert’s Perspective